Annual rings reflect a tree's growth conditions. They show how drought, competition and silvicultural interventions affect its growth. The stem disc of a young spruce illustrates this particularly well: it documents a prolonged period of almost negligible diameter growth, followed by a surprisingly strong response to thinning.

The tree's story begins in 1992 with vigorous early growth. The annual rings are up to five millimetres wide. From the late 1990s onwards, diameter growth declines. The stand gradually closes, increasing competition for light and water. The drought summer of 2003 further exacerbates the situation. In the following years, the spruce grows very little. Over the 14-year period from 2003 to 2017, its diameter increases by just three centimetres. In some years, the spruce produces barely half a millimetre of wood.

Thinning triggers renewed growth

In March 2018, the new forest owner takes action. He establishes extraction racks, releases selected future crop trees (crop trees) from competition and promotes mixed tree species. The spruce's response is immediately visible in its annual rings: their width increases from approximately 0.9 to 3.3 millimetres. In the following years, it even reaches up to 8.5 millimetres.

Looking at the basal area increment of this spruce stem disc, the increase following thinning is even more pronounced relative to early growth than the increase in annual ring width (Fig. 2). While the mean basal area increment before thinning (1992–2017) was 0.04 m² per year, it increased sixfold to 0.25 m² per year in the period after thinning (2018–2023). Over the same period, annual ring width increased by a factor of only 2.4.

The growth response to summer precipitation (total precipitation from April to September) can be clearly observed in this stem disc. From 2018 onwards, annual ring width increases in line with rising summer precipitation. It is not until the drought year of 2022 that the annual ring becomes narrower again. At 4.8 millimetres, however, it is still considerably wider than during the period of intense competition. In this spruce, competition in the densely stocked stand had a stronger growth-inhibiting effect than drought during the drought years studied.

The extent to which growth conditions had changed is also reflected in the tree's diameter: over the final six growing seasons following thinning, the tree increased its diameter by another 50%.

Greater Stability and Higher Timber Value

In addition to promoting diameter growth, thinning also encouraged the development of longer and wider crowns. This lowered the tree's centre of gravity, contributing to greater stability. Pedunculate oak, sycamore maple and wild cherry were also selectively favoured. Freed from competition, these mixed tree species were able to recover and become more stable.

In March 2024, the spruce was harvested due to the risk of a bark beetle outbreak and sold as a 1b grade log in fixed lengths. In summer 2026, timber of this grade could fetch prices of more than €100 per cubic metre. Without the substantial diameter increment following thinning, the tree would probably only have reached the lower-priced 1a grade or the industrial timber size class by the time of harvesting. Industrial timber generates approximately half the revenue per cubic metre and also incurs higher harvesting costs. Thinning therefore proved economically worthwhile for this individual tree.

What Can We Learn from This?

This example shows how forest owners can use targeted thinning to guide the growth of selected trees, improve their stability and favour mixed tree species. In the face of climate change, it is particularly important to tend spruce stands in good time and bring trees more quickly to larger, more marketable dimensions.

However, the effects of thinning on the growth of an entire stand cannot be inferred from a single tree. Up to a certain thinning intensity, the increased growth of released trees can compensate for the removal of competing trees. More intensive thinning, however, can also reduce growth per hectare. The poster therefore deliberately illustrates the development of a single future crop tree.

Poster Illustrating the Effects of Thinning

The Bavarian State Institute of Forestry (LWF) has used a poster to vividly illustrate the growth history of the spruce tree: Is Thinning Worthwhile? – The Growth of a Young Spruce (German only). It is particularly suitable for advising forest owners and shows how stand density, thinning and weather conditions are reflected in the annual rings.